UNBELIEVABLE! CRA Ombudsman Told Canadian Citizens of American Tax Laws

This is unbelievable! Canada’s Taxpayers’ Ombudsman gave Information for Canadian Citizens that are subject to American tax law.

It tells of the “obligation to report income and assets to IRS” for those born in the U.S., those who consider ties with U.S. to have been severed and those who immigrated to the U.S. or worked in the U.S.

This may come as a surprise to many people. There are scores of Canadians citizens who do not consider themselves to be American citizens because they have not lived in the US, let alone filed American tax returns, for decades. Yet, the US has laws in place that require them to disclose their revenue and assets to the IRS for tax purposes under the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FACTA) and the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA).

The Ombudsman tells us about FATCA:

The FATCA was enacted in 2010 by the United States Congress to target non-compliance by US taxpayers using foreign accounts. FATCA requires foreign financial institutions to report information to the IRS about financial accounts held by American taxpayers, or by foreign entities in which taxpayers hold a substantial ownership interest.



A FBAR is a form that must be completed and filed by an American citizen, resident, or entity that has a financial interest in, or signature authority over, foreign financial accounts where the aggregate value of those accounts exceeds $10,000 at any time during the calendar year.

The use of a FBAR assists the United States government in identifying individuals who may be using foreign financial institutions to bypass United States tax laws. FBARs help identify or trace funds used for illicit purposes or to identify unreported income maintained or generated abroad.


Not once does Canada’s Taxpayer Ombudsman bother to mention that CRA does not and will not collect taxes or penalties!!! So, I guess we shouldn’t consider him an Ombudsman for anyone tainted with a U.S. place of birth.

But, it’s clear the Ombudsman won’t help us in any way:

While the implications of, and procedures for, these US tax laws do not fall within the mandate of the Taxpayers’ Ombudsman, our office is committed to ensuring Canadian taxpayers receive clear information on issues that may have a negative impact and directing Canadian taxpayers to the appropriate area for assistance in meeting their tax obligations.

It also available in French: Des renseignements pour des citoyens canadiens qui sont assujettis aux lois fiscales des États-Unis

Thanks to WhiteKat for sending this to me. Someone provided it to her from government archives. It does not seem to be actively available on their site now, but this tells us what the Canadian government’s Taxpayers’ Ombudsman thinks of us and our rights as Canadian citizens:

“Congress has spoken.”

21 thoughts on “UNBELIEVABLE! CRA Ombudsman Told Canadian Citizens of American Tax Laws

  1. Duke of Devon

    How am I supposed to know other than what Worried told us? I don’t think you are being helpful. Enough said.

  2. WhiteKat


    It IS complicated, and as such, it is important to understand one’s particular situation fully. Something as basic as ‘When did I become a Canadian?’ is a key question that needs to be clearly answered for a person living in Canada with a US birthplace on his/her Canadian passport who is trying to make sense out of FATCA and US citizenship based taxation.

    I mean, you can do whatever you want with that information, including trying to keep it secret, but at least you need to be aware of it.

  3. WhiteKat

    @DukeOfDevon, I knew you were going to tell me to read her post again…lol.

    I know what she WROTE, but what did she really mean? Does she even KNOW? That WorriedinWindsor’s husband “received his Canadian citizenship in 1976” could mean he applied for and received his Canadian citizenship CERTIFICATE, a process which he might have misconstrued as actually becoming a Canadian. He may simply have obtained PROOF that he already was a Canadian since birth (having one Canadian parent at birth makes one a US citizen does it not?)

    Duals from birth have no birth certificate to prove their Canadian citizenship, and typically would go through this process of obtaining a Canadian citizenship certificate (something other Canadian born Canadians don’t need to acquire because they have a Canadian birth certificate for ID purposes) and one could confuse applying for a citizenship certificate with actually acquiring Canadian citizenship.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Optionally add an image (JPEG only)